Gibb’s and Kolb’s Reflective model In this report I am going to evaluate the difference between Gibbs () and Kolb (), drawing primarily on Gibbs’s reflective model. The Kolb cycle was published before Gibbs , David A. Kolb published his conception after an experimental test on a book “Experience as the Source of learning and development” while Gibbs published his theory by developing on the existing Kolb cycle (ehow[07/10/]). Kolb’s 6/14/ · Figure 1: Kolb’s Reflective Cycle The Gibbs cycle is based on six stages. It starts with describing what happened, then asking what do you feel and thinking about this experience, then the third stage is evaluation (was the experience good or bad?), next it analyses what can you make from this situation or event then last but not least drawing a conclusion-what could you done differently in this 4/21/ · Task Instructions 1. During Module 1 – 5, you were ask to produce a weekly journal to record your learnings each week. Based on these weekly journals, please write a word reflective report about your experience. 2. You are required to follow the four steps of Kolb’s learning cycle when writing the reflective report. [ ]
Kolb Reflective Model
Humans have been involved in the practice of reflection for millennia; as far back as BC, reflective essay using kolb learning cycle, Confucius wrote about the power of reflective practice for enhancing the human condition DunnGalvin et al. However, in modern times, one of the most influential proponents of reflective practice has been David Kolb Dennison, Like PiagetKolb considered learning to be experiential and largely self-driven.
Or, in his words. Moreover, Kolb argued that it is our ability to actively reflect on our experiences which facilitates our learning and development. According to Kolbthe four stages are interrelated via a clockwise pattern, with each stage feeding into the next.
When used as a reflective model, it is common for users to write down their responses to each of the four stages Heron,as will be explained later in this essay. Rather, the learner can take the time to reflect upon their experiences retrospectively and without feeling rushed. As mentioned, reflective practice is a common feature of the healthcare professions. Indeed, inthe Nursing and Midwifery Council NMC released a statement advising that, to be registered, all nursing practitioners should be involved in regular reflective practice.
Despite its influence, there has been some criticism levied towards this model Heron,as will be explored in the next section, reflective essay using kolb learning cycle. As mentioned, there are both strengths and weaknesses associated with this model, as summarised in the table below. It is empowering reflective essay using kolb learning cycle satisfying because it places the learner at the centre of their development reflective essay using kolb learning cycle This was quite unique in the s as pedagogy was more teacher-led during this time Dennison, This model does not acknowledge the role of unrequested peer feedback.
It can be used to develop emotional intelligence and resilience more generally DunnGalvin et al. Kolb did not provide a detailed account of how to conduct the reflective process Heron,though subsequent studies by other authors have provided detailed advice and guidance The Department for Health, UOL, It highlights the link between experiences, feelings, thoughts, and behaviours — it provides a holistic overview of the learning process and helps users to understand the links.
It has been argued that the four-stage approach is too simplistic and is not representative of human cognition Heron,though I would argue that the model does provide a holistic and convincing account of the relationship between experiences, feelings, thoughts, and behaviours — in a similar way to CBT Brooks, It encourages in-depth and considerate self-reflection because the reflective process takes quite a lot of time to complete.
A template for achieving this is provided in the following section. Generally speaking, it is advisable for learners to take regular breaks and not rush the reflective process UOL, Moreover, it is typically necessary to anonymise the details of others, particularly if working in the capacity of a nurse or other practitioner where patient confidentiality is a compliance requirement NMC, The column on the right indicates questions to ask or activities to try at each stage of the reflective cycle.
If my behaviour led to a negative experience, what will I try to do next time to facilitate a more positive outcome? If reflecting on a positive experience, how will I ensure that I create similar positive outcomes in the future? In the example, the nurse noticed their patient looked solemn and decided to reflect upon why this might be. Kolb first proposed his 4-stage theory of experiential learning in a book published in The full reference for this book is provided below and should be placed in the reference list of any reflective report.
Kolb, D. Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development Vol. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Thus, if engaging reflective essay using kolb learning cycle newer material, this should be cited accordingly. It began by situating the importance of reflection within the broader learning cycle, to show how Kolb saw reflective practice as a necessary pre-requisite for genuine development.
The essay then proceeded to explain the importance of reflective practice for certain professions, particularly nursing. In general, it is evident to see how reflective practice empowers learners. Brooks, M. The importance of using reflective practice when working with refugees, reflective essay using kolb learning cycle, asylum seekers and survivors of torture within IAPT.
The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist, 12 1, reflective essay using kolb learning cycle. Dennison, P. Compass: Journal of Teaching and Learning, 1 1. DunnGalvin, A. Applied reflective practice in reflective essay using kolb learning cycle and anaesthesiology. British Journal of Anaesthesia, 5 Kolb, D Kolb, A, reflective essay using kolb learning cycle. The Experiential Educator: Principles and Practices of Experenital Learning.
US: EBLS Press. Mantzourani, E. The role of reflective practice in healthcare professions: Next steps for pharmacy education and practice. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 15 12 NMC Regulators unite to support reflective practice across health and care.
Slade, M. International Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 13 2. The Department of Health The cycle of learning. Turesky, E. Academic Leadership: The Online Journal, 8 3 UOL David Kolb. Atkins and Murphy Model of Reflection. Borton's Model of Reflection.
Brookfield Reflective Model. Driscoll Model of Reflection. Gibbs Model of Reflection. Greenaway Model of Reflection. Marks-Moran and Rose, Mezirow Model of Transformative Learning.
Rolfe Reflective Model. Schon Reflective Model. Essay Writing Service UK provide a range of services for students who need a little extra push towards getting the results they need. Simply place an order online by clicking hereor alternatively feel free to send us an email or call one of our consultants who can discuss your requirements over the phone on ESSAY WRITING SERVICE UK TURNER HOUSE 9 - 10 MILL LANE ALTON, HANTS GU34 2QG.
About FAQ Why Choose Us? Why Do Students Use Us? Guarantees Subjects UK Writers Is This Cheating? Essay Fraud Resources Advice and Guidance Subjects Essay Formats Dissertation Help Free Samples Research Models Services Essays Essay Writing Service Assignment Writing Service Report Writing Service Coursework Writing Service Scholarship Essay Writing Service Admission Essay Writing Service Dissertations Dissertation Writing Service Dissertation Proposal Service Literature Review Writing Service PhD Writing Service Proofreading Blog Reviews Prices.
Kolb Reflective Model. Kolb Reflective Cycle: A Description and Evaluation Humans have been involved in the practice of reflection for millennia; as far back as BC, Confucius wrote about the power of reflective practice for enhancing the human condition DunnGalvin et al. Why use the Kolb reflective model? What fields use the Kolb reflective cycle? Why is Kolb a good reflective model?
Kolb model of reflection pros and cons As mentioned, there are both strengths and weaknesses associated with this model, as summarised in the table below. Positives Negatives It is empowering and satisfying because it places the learner at the centre of their development — This was quite unique in the s as pedagogy was more teacher-led during this time Dennison, It does not acknowledge the potential for cultural factors or gender differences Heron, How do you write a reflection using the Kolb model?
Reflection Watching and reflecting How did this experience make me feel? How might this experience have affected others? How did this experience compare to other similar experiences?
Conceptualisation Thinking Why might it have happened this way? What might have happened if I had have behaved differently? What could be the reason for this outcome? Active experimentation Doing behaving If my behaviour led to a negative experience, what will I try to do next time to facilitate a more positive outcome?
What skills might I need to develop in the future and how will I obtain these? References Brooks, M. Heron, J. Feeling and Personhood: Psychology in another key. London: Sage Kolb, D Piaget, J.
Kolb Learning Style
, time: 6:05Reflective Essay: Kolb’s ‘Experiential Learning Cycle’ - GRIN
6/14/ · Figure 1: Kolb’s Reflective Cycle The Gibbs cycle is based on six stages. It starts with describing what happened, then asking what do you feel and thinking about this experience, then the third stage is evaluation (was the experience good or bad?), next it analyses what can you make from this situation or event then last but not least drawing a conclusion-what could you done differently in this Gibb’s and Kolb’s Reflective model In this report I am going to evaluate the difference between Gibbs () and Kolb (), drawing primarily on Gibbs’s reflective model. The Kolb cycle was published before Gibbs , David A. Kolb published his conception after an experimental test on a book “Experience as the Source of learning and development” while Gibbs published his theory by developing on the existing Kolb cycle (ehow[07/10/]). Kolb’s Reflective Essay: Kolb’s ‘Experiential Learning Cycle’ College Swinburne University of Technology, Melbourne Course Human Resource Development Grade 2,3 Author Barbara Bilyk (Author) Year Pages 13 Catalog Number V ISBN (eBook) ISBN (Book) File size KB Language English
No comments:
Post a Comment